I attended a seminar on ethics today, gathering my CEU’s for this round of licensing renewal. Six hours of listening to a very well-educated, well-intentioned woman talking about how to figure out what is right and wrong. There are lots of times when, in my profession, we really don’t have a clear black/white right/wrong situation, and we have to do our best to mediate a solution that is best for everyone involved, while causing the least harm.
Where I choke and have a really hard time being quiet is when the issue presented could have been avoided completely if the person involved had simply lived according to biblical principles. I grew up in a simpler time. All the shadings of gray between right and wrong were a lot easier to resolve in my early years, because we lived by a system of absolutes. Not any more.
Example: A man is deployed overseas. Before he leaves, he and his wife have a conversation in which he makes it clear that unfaithfulness is something he couldn’t tolerate, and he’d probably “do away with” an unfaithful wife. Sooooo she has an affair while he’s gone and comes up HIV positive. The ethical dilemma? Whether or not to tell her husband. Will he truly kill her? Does the therapist this wife is talking with have an ethical responsibility to tell or not to tell? Isn’t the life of the soldier in danger if he doesn’t know she has HIV? Doesn’t he have a right to know what he’s risking? But if the wife or the therapist tell the soldier his wife was unfaithful, he might kill her!
What to do, what to do??
And I’m sitting there thinking, “DUH!” This kind of “ethical dilemma” would not exist if the wife had simply chosen–yes, chosen–to stay true to her spouse. Millions of other wives have managed to do that down through the history of warfare. She chose not to honor him with faithfulness, and now she’s in a really awful mess. And what makes it worse, in my mind, is that she’s looking for a way out! Is she worried about protecting her spouse from HIV or herself from a very unpleasant, possibly dangerous, confrontation?
Well, but (you say) you don’t know the circumstances! Maybe she just was so lonely blahblahblah. Baloney. We make choices in our lives, and those choices ALWAYS carry consequences. After the affair is too late to be worried about getting caught, getting HIV. Now she needs to figure out how to be honest with her husband without getting herself murdered–which, by the way, is not an okay choice for her husband.
There are so many things wrong here that it’s amazing we only spent a few–unprofitable–minutes discussing it. NO ONE said, “Well, she should have never committed adultery!” It was just taken as a given that “these things happen” and you have to figure out how to go forward from there.
We are not teaching absolute rights and wrongs any more, and as a result we’re in an absolute mess.
Psalm 118:8. “It is better to trust in the Lord than to put confidence in man.”
I don’t know which Bob Jones said it: Do right because it’s right to do right! Sure makes life simpler.
10 thoughts on “Ethics”
I could not do your job. I has to be God’s calling. I’d be sitting there, eyebrows furrowed together, speaking in much too loud a voice saying “You did WHAT?”
Two wrongs do not make a right either.
or just two choices on the shelf– serving God or serving self!
Thanks, Linda and Shepherd’s Presence! It helps to know that I am not alone in my frustration with giving ones who I care very much for, Godly counsel, even pointing them to specific Scriptures, and not seeing the fruit yet! I will pray for you Linda, as your position as a counselor does not always afford you even the blessing of SHARING that counsel! You are bearing a Spiritual Burden there, ad we all need to hold you up in prayer.
There can never be too much prayer. Thanks.
Absolutes should absolutely be taught. Absolutely!
Maybe we also miss the boat in teaching and warning about absolute consequences, which unfortunately are not always administered the way the should be by mankind. Too foten we “overlook” things that should NEVER be overlooked.
Oops – often
Agree. “Let it go this time” is a sure way to start down that proverbial slippery slope.
WOW! Linda this is such a very hard subject to cover. When I was a Police Sergeant I taught a class on Ethics to the new police officers. A basic right or wrong thing to if certain actions present themselves. Without going to the Bible and religion, not permitted to go there, it was difficult to get through on the topics I really wanted to cover.
The presenter yesterday was very careful not to mention religious or biblical principles in any way. And really, without God, you can’t teach this subject with any definitive power. It’s all based on human nature and a whole bunch of psychobabble. Bleagh.